Link Leads Blog · October 26, 2026
A lead you already paid for is a sunk cost. The only question left is what it costs to turn it into a sale now, and how that compares with buying a new lead or a live transfer. Here is the math with real beta numbers, and what happens when the rates move against you.
The money you spent on last spring's leads is gone whether you work them again or not. That makes the decision simpler than it feels. The question isn't whether those leads were worth what you paid. It's what it costs from here to turn one of them into a sale, and whether that's cheaper than every other way of getting a sale.
Here's that math with real numbers from the first Resurge beta batch, and an honest check on what happens when your numbers come in lower.
Cost per sale = (monthly fee + transfers × transfer fee) ÷ policies closed.
On the beta batch: 1,000 leads produced 16 transfers and 4 policies. At Solo pricing ($149/month plus $12 per transfer), that's $149 + $192 = $341, or about $85 per sale. No lead cost is included, because the leads were already owned.
Vendor live transfers commonly run $35 to $60 each, which is the range Resurge's calculator uses. If you closed vendor transfers at the same 1 in 4 rate as the beta batch, every sale would cost $140 to $240 in transfer fees alone.
That close-rate assumption is generous in both directions, so use your own. If you already buy transfers, you know your close rate on them. Plug it in. The structural difference stays the same either way: a Resurge transfer costs $8 to $12 plus a share of the monthly fee, and it comes from a lead you already own.
Fresh leads are a different trade. They're more responsive, cost more per lead, and still take dialing time. The cleanest comparison is your own cost per acquisition on your last few fresh batches: total lead spend divided by policies written. If that number is above $85, the old file is worth a look before the next order goes in. If it's well below, keep buying fresh leads and run the old file through anyway. It isn't competing with your new leads for your time, because you only pick up when someone has already said yes.
The Resurge pricing calculator's default assumes 3 transfers per 100 leads. The beta batch did 1.6. So here's the same Producer-plan estimate re-run at the lower beta rate.
At the calculator default: about 2,165 leads worked a month (500 a week) gives about 65 transfers, for $499 + $650 = $1,149, or roughly $18 per live call.
At the beta rate: the same 2,165 leads give about 35 transfers, for $499 + $350 = $849, or roughly $24 per live call. At a 1-in-4 close rate that's about 9 policies, around $97 per sale.
Even at the lower rate, the cost per live call stays under half of what a vendor transfer costs. Where the math breaks down is volume. On a file too small to fill the plan, the monthly fee is spread across fewer transfers, which is why the Solo plan exists. It's sized for 250 leads a week.
None of these numbers count dialing hours, because there aren't any. Working 2,000 aged leads by hand is days of dials, voicemails and callbacks for a few conversations. Working them through Resurge is an upload and a phone that rings when someone says yes. Whatever your hour is worth, those hours go back to fresh leads, renewals and closing.
The beta is one batch, and your file will produce its own numbers. The 14-day trial has no platform fee (you only pay for transfers you answer), so the cheapest way to get a real cost per sale for your book is to upload a file and measure it.